Glen Lake Board Member on School Funding
Glen Lake School Board trustee Jeff Smith has written an excellent letter to the Free Press regarding education funding inequities in Michigan that everyone should read.
Consider that this year the state will pay my school district in northern Michigan about $7,000 to educate my daughter, while at the same time, Birmingham’s school district, between state and local taxes, will have about $12,000 to educate a girl there. Multiplied from kindergarten through 12th grade, that difference would mean the girl in Birmingham receives a $156,000 education while my daughter receives a $91,000 education — a $65,000 gap.
Read Make district funding more equal by Jeff Smith in the Detroit Free Press.
What is the correlation between dollars spent on students and student
achievement? I have read that the highest performing students on the
college boards (ACT and/or SAT) were from the northern tier midwestern
states like Minnesota, North Dakota, etc. If so, it suggests that the
amount spent on each student is not as important as the family and
culture they grow up in. It is not just a question of dollars spent.
Consider this…if Jeff wants to educate his children at the same spending levels of the
Birmingham schools he is free to move to Birmingham. Those parents sacrifice much
to afford to live where their kids get a top notch public education and the good schools
have driven up the cost of housing in Birmingham. Its the price people are willing to pay!
Is Glen expecting the parents in Birmingham to write a personal check to pay
for his kids education. Oops, I forgot, they already do!
Birmingham property taxes are more than double what Glen Lakes are,
and assessed values are huge. You can compare at the State’s web site.
For example, a homesteaded property valued at $100,000 pays $4,405 per year in Birmingham
vice $1783 in Glen Lake. This example doesn’t even consider the astonomical premium
Birmingham residents pay for housing.
You want more dollars for education, start by doubling YOUR own property taxes.
My guess is that Birmingham residents ALREADY pay thousands of dollars towards
underwriting the cost of educating Glen Lake and many other of the rest of State’s students.
What Glen is really asking for is for Birmingham residents to pay even MORE
of the cost of educating YOUR kids.
I say, if the grass is so much greener in Birmingham – then move. But don’t sit in
Glen Arbor and expect “others” to pay MORE for YOUR kids education.
You chose where you wanted to live and are already getting more than your fair share of
other people’s money
The system is unfair…but its communities like Birmingham that are the ones
getting the shaft – not Glen Lake.
James, you’re actually incorrect. Like Birmingham, Glen Lake is a net exporter of school aid moneys.
Under Proposal A, a district CANNOT raise millage rates and increase school revenues. It all goes to the state and then is given back according to the foundation grant. If it were the case that districts were allowed to assess supplemental millages, that would work very well for a district like Glen Lake.